Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Subscribe To Innovative
Posts
Comments
The Best of the Blogs
The Bookshelf Author Blogs
-
And Suddenly, We Have a Mail-Order Bride!8 months ago
-
Demo: 5 Reasons You Need The X Theme5 years ago
-
YA Fresh’s Series Finale.11 years ago
-
Which cover do you like best?11 years ago
-
the kitchen sink13 years ago
-
-
Find Us Fast!15 years ago
-
-
-
-
-
-
About Me
- Gabrielle
- I'm the primary blogger of Innovative: A Word for the Teen. In the past, I've done everything from guest-blogging for New Moon to writing a column for KidMagWriters.com, and being published 40+ times in between. I write sporadic reviews of new books from a writer's perspective, and occasionally offer advice to teen writers when I'm not being a college freshman. Find out more about my success in Chicken Soup: Extraordinary Teens, now available in stores.
4 comments:
I read Eragon. I am impressed with Paolini's getting published and all, but I really am not very impressed with Eragon. I started Eldest... read like the first page, but never finished it.
It was written well enough, but the plot was a bit too simple for me. And the characters seemed too nice and too simple.
But a good word, it did have a certain charm in it's simplicity, and I can see why so many kids/teens would like it. But me... I feel I could do better. :)
Hmm... hard question. I liked Eragon, but I thought it was too stereotypical. Eldest got dumber as it went. Eragon is entirely too emotional, and doesn't give up on the wrong things (Arya...). I'm going to read the third book just to see what happens, but I don't really expect to like it. :-)
As for Christopher himself, I think it's amazing, and a credit to his perseverance, that he was published at 18, and I'm not saying he's a bad writer! I just think his first published story is too stereotypical/copycat. It will be interesting to see what he does as he gets older.
OK, good things first. I think Paolini is a genius for plot and the scope of an epic; he handles a lot of crazy threads and details without going crazy. With time, he's going to mature into a really good fantasy author.
However... originality isn't his virtue, as was mentioned. I hated Eldest, to be frank. The whole Arya saga is way too predictable and boring, and he CANNOT WRITE ROMANCE. He just can't. And some of the writing in "Eldest" was very bad.
But I think he proves that people love epic fantasies, the way High School Musical proved people love musicals. Some genres never die.
Does HSM really count as a "musical"? ;-) I hated that one too, lol.
Post a Comment